Using an Employee\’s Input to Write a Performance Evaluation

As we approach the end of the year, you may be starting to think about writing annual performance evaluations for your employees. Soliciting the employee\'s feedback before you begin writing can provide you with helpful and specific input. Here are some tips for soliciting and using employee input in the performance evaluation:

Remind the employee that while you have kept records about their performance, you may have missed something along the way. You are providing an opportunity for the employee to highlight their accomplishments over the past year.

Ask for specific examples including a list of accomplishments, process improvements they recommended and/or implemented, letters or emails of commendation they received that have not been forwarded to you, training completed that you may have not recorded, and anything else that they feel is important to share that will give you a complete look at their performance.

DO NOT ask the employee to fill out the evaluation form on his or her own and submit it to you. This approach leads to the employee feeling as if the evaluation duties are being delegated. Employees want your opinion, however you convey it. Those supervisors who ask their employees to complete their own evaluations and who do not add significantly to the content of the employee\'s evaluation are seen as lazy, as cowards, or as both.

Use a standard format for soliciting feedback from an employee about their work performance. The following example could be used to ask the employee for their input and ideas:

Employee Self-Evaluation Form

This is to confirm our meeting on _________________ to discuss your performance over the last __________ months/year and to create a plan for your performance for the coming year.

Your input is essential to the success of our meeting and I value your ideas. Please respond to the following questions in as much detail as possible. I will use this information as I prepare the performance evaluation documents.

Please return this sheet to me by _______________ so that I can incorporate your perspectives into the evaluation.

1. What do you consider to be your most significant accomplishments since your last performance evaluation?

2. What were your greatest challenges since your last performance evaluation?

3. What new challenges or goals would you like to pursue in the upcoming rating period?

4. What can the organization or I do to help you improve your performance over the next rating period?

5. Please tell me about anything else that I need to consider in preparing your performance evaluation.

Present the self-evaluation as an optional exercise. While it is recommended that supervisors ask for input to ensure that performance events and details are not overlooked, if an employee chooses not to provide input to the process, they should not be required to do so.

Writing a performance evaluation doesn\'t have to be painful. By focusing on specific accomplishments and involving the employee in the process, you can use this opportunity to enhance communication between you and the employee.

Marnie E. Green is Principal Consultant of the Chandler, AZ-based Management Education Group, Inc. Green is a speaker, author, and consultant who helps organizations develop confident leaders. Contact Green at phone: 480-705-9394 email: mgreen@managementeducationgroup.com web site: \r http://www.managementeducationgroup.com

We offer this article on a nonexclusive basis. You may reprint or repost this material as long as Marnie Green\'s name and contact information are included.

Hitting for the Cycle as a Performance Manager
In baseball, "the cycle" means that a hitter earns a single, double, triple, and home run in the same game. In Painless Performance Evaluations: A Pra...

The Fundamentals on Conducting Employee Evaluation
Employee evaluation is indeed one aspect that businesses cannot do without. This is because conducting such an evaluation is very helpful for any busi...

People Management - Employees Are Saying This About Our Managers
Part of our business is to facilitate employee feedback forums. In these sessions, we have neutral sessions with employee groups about a variety of to...

Performance Documentation
Maintaining complete and legally defensible performance documentation is the first step to a painless performance evaluation.Supervisors should mainta...

Six Easy Steps to Better Performance Appraisals
Pity the poor manager, staring at a blank page, trying to come up with something to write for an employee's annual performance appraisal. Make your l...

Conducting Exit Interviews
Exit interviews can be as important as recruitment interviews. However, many organisations either do not complete them or they file the data away with...

Setting Performance Goals
The New Year is a great time to establish new performance goals with employees and to clarify your performance expectations for the coming quarter and...

Making The Most of HR KPI
Any company in just about any type of industry aims to have its workforce made up of employees who are very productive. In ensuring this high level of...

The Inquiry Skill - Ask What They Think
Employees want to feel appreciated and listened to and to be involved and informed. That is, they want (and need) open two-way communication with thei...

Important Performance Management Tips
Performance management is all about providing your people with the right atmosphere and the right motivational elements to help them cope better with ...

How To Have Employees That Work For Success
If you want to become a great manager of your business, there are a few key things that you must know. Your employees are important to you, and you w...

Reducing Employee Stress
If you want motivated and high-energy employees in your business, then create an environment that reduces workplace stress. Not only do stressed emplo...

Why Performance Evaluations Are So Painful
There are three types of organizations when it comes to performance evaluations. The first type does not use any evaluation or what they use is adhoc...

How to Manage Motivation and Performance
The relationship between motivation and performance is often talked about but not many organizations are making concrete efforts to study it in detail...

Here is a Method For Managing Your Friends In The Workplace - Follow These 7 Simple Tips
Are you a new manager? Have you been promoted recently? Is some of your staff also your friends? Do you know how easy it is to loose all respect when ...