SEO, SEM and Politics

That the search engines can be manipulated is no secret, but most SEOs try a positive approach and define their strategies as ethical or "white-hat."

In Aaron Wall's dictionary, there is no such thing as ethical SEO because, no matter how you look at it, once you employ a technique (any) to manipulate the search engines, you "SPAM." The only question is what kind of spam is acceptable from a Google perspective?

Part of the answer comes from Google's Webmaster Guidelines (quality guidelines - specific guidelines), more comes from Bruce Clay's SEO code of ethics, and if that's not enough you could always rely on an answer from authority SEO professionals.

Now back to SEO as a dirty business.

Strangely enough in real life it is a lot easier to harm than to heal. Somehow supremacy and power are achieved faster through war than peaceful negotiations. No surprise here: negotiating peacefully takes time to find a compromise which, in many situations, is not what the parts involved hoped to achieve.

SEM is quite similar. For every winner, there's a loser, and many companies that rely on Google for traffic employ questionable SEO tactics to achieve good rankings for their most competitive keyword phrases.

But this is nothing compared to those that employ "political tricks" to harm their competitors. Forbes lists in "The Saboteurs of Search" two techniques (out of seven): Google bowling and Google insulation.

Google bowling is pure evil and it deals with how to frame a competitor's site as a spamming site to convince Google to drop its rankings. This type of negative SEO deals with links -- and many links at once. These links are generated automatically, over a short period of time, using special software. They'll mostly come from bad neighbors and they'll all have the same anchor text, to make the spam picture complete. Google is just a machine, so there's no real way for this machine to know who is behind the link spam. The "guilty" site might lose its position in the SERP or even get banned. Some sites never recover after a Google ban, others see their rankings vanishing and their pages landing into the supplemental results and they never learn why.

If something like this has happened to your site, all you can really do is to find out who hates you so much. Google bowling is not the only negative SEO technique that might hurt a competitor site.

Tattling, as correctly identified by Forbes, is something that even Google's Matt Cutts encourages, by asking people to report sites that buy links. I really wonder how Google verifies such complaints.

Basically anyone can assume that a contextual link in one of my blog entries is a paid link (what if I monetize my site with V7 contextual?).

There are many other questionable SEO strategies to demolish competition. I happen to consider them a waste of time and energy. The Forbes article quoted above contains a pretty interesting statement: "Matt Cutts, a senior software engineer for Google, says that piling links onto a competitor's site to reduce its search rank isn't impossible, but it's extremely difficult."

If negative SEO is difficult, we are prone to believe that it seldom happens. I think that, in some niches, it happens quite often. But these are simple theories. As long as I do not have the data to back them up, I prefer to keep my analysis to a minimum of delivering information.

There are simpler ways to harm competition. Scrapper sites harm writers by copying their content. And it is not that difficult to understand where the "harm" lies.

For example, when a scrapper copies the content of your site, your rankings are harmed, especially if the scrapper site happens to have more authority than yours. There is not much you can do to protect your rankings and your copyright. But if you decide to report the guilty site to the search engine (file a compliant) the search engine will remove the site from its index for 10 days, to give you (the copyright holder) the time to sue for infringement.

Many bloggers wake up one day to find their articles duplicated on obscure sites, MFA sites and so on. They are often frustrated and they ask in forums the classic: what can I do if someone copies my content. Well, now you have a possible answer: you don't need to go to court to punish a site for copyright infringement. It is enough to file a complaint at Google and you've got the guilty site out of the Google SERPs for at least 10 days.

Careful though, a fraudulent copyright complaint can get you in trouble, and not just with the search engines. So don't just go around filing complaints. The Google ban theoretically lasts for just 10 days, but the trust rank of the accused site will lower. Another similar complaint and the site's integrity will be seriously questioned. Just remember: what goes around, comes around.

Mihaela Lica is online marketing expert at Red Dog Communications Luxembourg.

Politics, Religion, Race; Conversational No-No’s in Business
Do not destroy all your positive displacement and high energy and customer confidence by discussing politics in your small business. Remember not ever...

Change Management and the Affects on Productivity
One of the biggest concerns and the reason why so many consultants and MBA business schools study change management is because it directly affects the...

Change Management and Smooth Transitions
For many corporations change management is a time of controversy and chaos and yet it need not be. Is all change management like this? No, those tea...

Networking and Cleavage Issues
If you are into networking to help your business grow then you are already a smart marketer and a smart cookie. Often in the past when I was fully eng...

2007 Change Management and Averting Chaos
All things in life experience change and everywhere we look everywhere we go we observe change. We see the seasons change, the weather change, our bod...

Business Improvement Project Mechanics, Business Dynamics, Corporate Optics and Office Politics
This article looks at how business dynamics impact the orderly improvement of the business.Business Dynamics are internal/external pressures to streng...

Senior Adults Discover the Joys of Computer Literacy
It seems every day lately, seniors using computers are making their presence known. CNN.com published an editorial in mid-November about the rising nu...

Change: It Doesn’t Have To Be So Difficult
The old adage goes: no one likes change. But I believe that people enjoy change; they just dont know how to change without disrupting their status quo...

Networking 101
Networking is not about using people. It's about taking advantage of all available resources to make sure you get remembered - in a positive way.Many ...

Potential Stolen Away
There was every reason to believe that Bob was going to do well in life. He had a creative intelligence and an organized approach to his profession th...

TPC Analysis
TPC Analysis seeks to identify, label and understand sources of resistance as either Technical (sunk costs, lack of skills, and lack of critical resou...

Holiday Networking - Ten Tips to Create New Relationships and Shine at Any Event
Holidays are a great time to schmooze and network - just remember the difference! Schmoozing is all about mingling with people you know, like colleagu...

Pilots Age 60 Rule - Where Is It Now?
Probably one of the most contentious issues of recent times in the aviation community is the proposed changes to the age 60 rule. As most of the reade...

Managing In Tough Times - Communication Is Key
Change is guaranteed and change is constant. Based on recent studies, 72% of those reading this will be doing something different in 2 years. There wi...

Five Forms of Power for Women Who Mean Business!
For women in business, there is a difference between being taken seriously and being overbearing. People can at times be intimidated by a woman of p...