Charisma in the Workplace

Television producer Mark Goodson invariably responded to the question, How do you select people to appear as contestants on your shows? with the same answer: We look for three things. Personality, personality and personality. Mr. Goodsons response applies not only to the selection of people to appear on TV reality and game shows, but to applicants for high-level management jobs.

When jobs of high caliber, such as COO, CEO and President, are vacated, there are many qualities to be considered in an applicant, qualities such as capability, experience, and education. But the quality that is most likely to facilitate acquiring such lucrative positions, and theres no doubt about it among the experts, is that part of some personalities called charisma.

Not everyone has charisma, the quality that gives a personality influence over large numbers of people, people who follow not because they have to, but because they want to. Jack Welch, GEs former Chairman and Chief Executive, has genuine charisma. So does actor Jack Nicholson, and the late columnist, Mike Royko. Mark Goodson himself had it. Harry S. Truman had it, and Seabiscuit, the Thoroughbred racehorse, had it.

Charisma can be a trait that, while helping employees in management get to the top of their professions, can cause some serious problems later, if a dark side shows itself. Some top executives who look good to their peers and their bosses and who do well on most assessments, turn out to be terrible for their companies, and end up being costly by creating poor morale, excessive turnover, and reducing productivity. Sometimes they can ruin a company altogether.

Many corporations hire experts to handle the job interview, experts who know how to differentiate between genuine charisma, of which self-confidence is the basis, and variations of it, which have a dark side, an almost grandiose sense of certainty with a disdain for subordinates.

One whose assessments expose the dark side, if its lurking within a charismatic job candidate, is Robert Hogan, Ph. D., President, Hogan Assessment Systems (HAS), Tulsa OK. HAS pioneered the use of personality measures for making organizational decisions by predicting on-the-job performances, particularly aspects associated with attitude. Dr. Hogans 25 years of development, refinement and validation supply the tools which provide valuable information for in-depth developmental feedback.

Besides intelligence and a knack for strategic planning, good managers have enormous charm and energy, said Dr. Hogan. Charisma ... concerns sparkling, shining, and seeming very attractive. The key word is seeming.

Three of the 10 major personality disorders are also characterized by charisma, said Dr. Hogan, they are Narcissistic, Psychopathic, and Histrionic personalities. Narcissism is about being charming but arrogant think Bill Clinton. Narcissists act as though normal rules dont apply to them.

Psychopathy is about being charming but utterly untrustworthy think (former Enron CFO) Jeffrey Fastow. Histrionic is about being charming but capable of only superficial relationships, and being distractible think any movie star. (Charismatic) people light up a room and make a huge impact on strangers...

When asked if two people were eligible for the same position, would the one with the attractive personality get the job even if the other had better qualifications, Dr. Hogan answered emphatically: Charisma trumps accomplishments and integrity every time.

One way to tell the difference between charisma and narcissism, says Dr. Hogan, is the degree to which they are willing to share credit for success, and to accept blame for failure. Narcissists wont ... accept blame. They are particularly good at ingratiating themselves with their seniors but brutalize their juniors.

To the question, Do women employees trust a male leader more than a female leader, Dr. Hogan replied, My wife does.

Others do not disagree with Mrs. Hogan.

Howard S. Schwartz, Ph.D., Professor of Organizational Behavior at Oakland University, Rochester, MI, and author of Narcissistic Process and Corporate Decay: The Theory of the Organization Ideal, (New York University Press) believes theres a difference between male and female charismatics.

Dr. Schwartz theorizes that male charisma has to do with strength, while female charisma has to do with sex. It wasnt Menelaus face that launched a thousand ships, it was Helens. Anybody who doesnt think (sex) has to do with power just isnt thinking.

Within the confines of a charismatic personality in corporate life, Dr. Schwartz theorizes that women are more inclined to act in accordance with what is going on within the relationship, whereas men are not so much involved with the specifics of relationships but are more tied into the rules that structure the organization, living more in the abstract. Thats why, he says, how (men) feel at the moment doesnt have that much bearing on how they act. (They) can work productively with people that they hate. Women have a harder time doing that.

But Schwartz agrees on the dangers of narcissistic management. He says it insulates managers from reality: If the top management of an organization does something that causes the organization to head toward a cliff, (it) is going to go over the cliff and the only thing most people can do is to cross their fingers and update their resumes.

Sandra Davis, Ph.D, founder and CEO of MDA Consulting Group in Minneapolis, utilizes HAS, in part, to help cull job applicants for MDAs corporate clients. Dr. Davis herself is a fascinating conversationalist, a charismatic one-time classical pianist whose taste in music ranges from Brahams to Willie Nelson and the Rolling Stones.

In divining the difference between charisma and narcissism in job applicants for corporate clients, Dr. Davis, who practices objectivity with a heart, interviews with such questions as:

Tell me about the last time you made a mistake.

Tell me about when something didnt work out the way you wanted it to. When was the last time you got feedback from someone who didnt agree with you? What will people who know you say is your downside?

These are intriguing questions which, Dr. Davis has found, Narcissists are incapable of answering, except with glib responses, because A person turned inside truly cannot see themselves as having made any mistakes and cant accept feedback.

In discussing criteria for leadership, Dr. Davis, who believes corporations can make mistakes when hiring someone from outside their organization, because that person has not demonstrated the ability of leadership to the employees, states Initial charisma isnt quite the same as being attracted to human spirit, depth of character, (or having) the thought, Ill follow them...

Although it appears to be difficult to uncover a genuine charismatic, its not impossible. One executive, whose name was repeatedly mentioned throughout these interviews as an ideal, intellectually flexible and charismatic leader, was Xerox Corporations President and CEO: Anne M. Mulcahy.

Colleagues describe Anne Mulcahy as a problem-solving optimist who can deliver bad news well, bring the required players to the table, and keep them talking and inspired. When she took over leadership of Xerox, the company was struggling to right itself after managerial mistakes had plunged it into deep financial trouble.

Mulcahy frequently speaks of having learned teamwork in her youth, where she was treated by her parents no differently from her four brothers. She is one of only 10 women in the United States to lead a Fortune 500 company. Today, she says, It always felt absolutely natural to be the only woman in a room full of men.

In view of the recent rise in known executive misbehavior, perhaps it would be universally beneficial for medical research to concentrate on cloning not sheep, but charismatic leaders.

###

http://www.maggievanostrand.com

Maggie Van Ostrand\'s award-winning humor column appears in local hard copy newspapers and online publications in the United States, Mexico and Canada.

Her articles appear regularly in the Chicago Tribune, and have appeared in the Boston Globe, Newsday, the Philadelpha Inquirer, Amarillo Globe-News, Sun-Sentinel, and many other national newspapers, as well as national and niche magazines.

A prolific writer, Maggie churns out three humor and one human interest columns weekly, plus a monthly humor column.

She is a member of National Society of Newspaper Columnists, the Erma Bombeck Writers Workshop, and the Society of Women Writers and Journalists in the U.K.

Maggie was also a judge of the worldwide Erma Bombeck Writers\' Contest in 2004, 2005 and 2006, and judge of 2007 Arizona Press Club Award for journalism.

Coping With Change in Your Workplace - Be Proactive, Not Reactive
Admit it, you like things to be constant. When things are constant you are in control. Being in control feels good. But sometimes there are external f...

Corporate Workplace Violence Plan - Will Yours Fail When You Need It Most?
You have your company's workplace violence plan all finished. It's loaded with all of the preventative and reporting procedures you think you need. ...

Islam in the Workplace
At the turn of the last century, 80% of the Arabs that immigrated to the United States were Christian. Today, more than 60% of Arab immigrants are Mus...

Here is a Method For Managing Your Friends In The Workplace - Follow These 7 Simple Tips
Are you a new manager? Have you been promoted recently? Is some of your staff also your friends? Do you know how easy it is to loose all respect when ...

Managing Change in the Workplace
Change is exhilarating. Change is terrifying. Change is badly needed around here. Whatever your attitude is to change, it is the most reliable compani...

Workplace Prescription Drug Abuse: Employees Abusing Prescription Drugs Is Bad Medicine
Prescription drugs are prescribed by doctors to cure people, so how can they be harmful? Because everyone's body chemistry and tolerance to drugs is d...

Workplace Diversity - What It Really Means
We didn't all come over in the same ship, but we're all in the same boat. -- Bernard M. BaruchMany people regard diversity with some skepticism -- as ...

How to Implement Change in the Workplace Without Sending Your Staff to a Psychiatrist
It seem that the only time people are open to change is when what they have always done no longer works for them. In other words when our needs are no...

Three Major Trends In The Workplace
The workplace as we know it is changing. Employers will need to adjust how they conduct business in order to better recruit and maintain qualified can...

Are You a Helicopter Boss?
The term "helicopter parent" is quite the ubiquitous expression today, especially in schools and educational institutions. A helicopter parent is a pa...

Why Offer Employee Orientation?
Often in smaller retail companies there is a practice of bringing employees into the business without properly orienting them to the company, the work...

Reducing Employee Stress
If you want motivated and high-energy employees in your business, then create an environment that reduces workplace stress. Not only do stressed emplo...

Diversity Training - How to Identify and Resolve Unconscious Discrimination in the Workplace
The Changing Face of Workplace DiscriminationIt seems that the face of workplace discrimination is changing into a less easily recognizable one. Worke...

Making The Most of HR KPI
Any company in just about any type of industry aims to have its workforce made up of employees who are very productive. In ensuring this high level of...

5’s - Lean Manufacturing Foundation
The 5S system is widely used today in a very large percentage of manufacturing businesses. Many non-manufacturing companies also employ the discip...