Balancing Top-Down and Bottom-Up Change Processes

\"Grass-roots change presents senior managers with a paradox: directing a \'nondirective\' change process. The most effective senior managers in our study recognized their limited power to mandate corporate renewal from the top. Instead, they defined their roles as creating a climate for change, then spreading the lessons of both successes and failures. Put another way, they specified the general direction in which the company should move without insisting on the specific solutions.\" Michael Beer, Russell Eisenstat, and Bert Spector, Why Change Programs Don\'t Produce Change

Organization change and improvement planning calls for systems, processes, and discipline. These are often top-down, organization-wide approaches. Developing change champions and supporting local initiatives takes leadership. Like innovation, many change and improvement paths are discovered accidentally by change champions blazing new trails (strategic opportunism).

These can then be formalized and made passable for the whole wagon train. This is an important part of organizational learning. Change and improvement processes evolve and change to fit the shifting environment and what\'s being learned about what works and what doesn\'t. Both top-down and local, or bottom-up, approaches are needed. The challenge is finding the right balance.

Managers play a pivotal role in the success or failure of any organization change or improvement effort. Their behavior is the single most important variable in the process. But among those managers working hard to visibly and actively lead their organization improvement effort, many fill only half their role. They personally signal values, plan, direct, and coordinate. That\'s vital. But what most fail to do as well is follow and serve. They don\'t manage (or may not even have thought about) the servant-leadership change and improvement paradox.

The leadership component of the change and improvement paradox involves managing the Context and Focus (vision, values, and purpose), identifying customers/partners and the gaps to be closed, and cultivating the environment for innovation and organization learning. Improvement leadership means establishing goals and priorities and setting the improvement planning process and framework.

However, the service side of the paradox is about \"followership.\" This starts with recognition that the organization is full of current or potential change champions. As members or leaders of operational and improvement teams, these people are much closer to the action than anyone in senior management. So they have a much better sense of which change and improvement tactics will work. But perhaps even more importantly, they hold the balance of implementation power. Without their commitment, the best-laid plans will fail (another major cause of \"execution problems\").

Think Corporately, Act Locally

Balancing top-down improvement planning with local initiatives involves identifying and supporting the change champions, innovative teams, and other efforts that are already underway. At the corporate or organization-wide level, change and improvement planning includes the establishment of strategic imperatives, improvement objectives, setting the broad improvement map (such as the infrastructure and process to be used), and developing preliminary plans.

Part of that planning entails connecting to and incorporating the existing pockets of change and improvement. These teams and champions have often gone through the innovation and organizational learning steps of exploration and experimentation. Their (often unorthodox and unofficial) approaches and experiences can be a gold mine of learning for the organization improvement process. As these early innovators are educated to the full organization improvement plan, they\'re shown how to adapt the new process and tools. They can use them to build on their earlier experiences and move ever closer to their change and improvement goals.

Jim Clemmer is a bestselling author and internationally acclaimed keynote speaker, workshop/retreat leader, and management team developer on leadership, change, customer focus, culture, teams, and personal growth. During the last 25 years he has delivered over two thousand customized keynote presentations, workshops, and retreats. Jim\'s five international bestselling books include The VIP Strategy, Firing on All Cylinders, Pathways to Performance, Growing the Distance, and The Leader\'s Digest. His web site is http://www.clemmer.net/articles.

Managing Change in the Workplace
Change is exhilarating. Change is terrifying. Change is badly needed around here. Whatever your attitude is to change, it is the most reliable compani...

Design Of Experiments With Six Sigma
The Basic Concepts Underlying DOESix Sigma stresses making alterations in existing business processes for improving overall efficiency. To make effect...

Bottom Cowling Installation on Light Aircraft
Re-installing the bottom cowling of a light aircraft by your self can be a really tough job. They are cumbersome, awkward and nearly impossible to ins...

Small Business Management - A Balancing Act - Part One
So you have taken the plunge, and embarked on the painful, yet rewarding journey of starting you own business. With so many books on small business ma...

Depression And Low Thyroid Function
Millions of people from around the world suffer from depressive illnesses. At one time or another, most men and women have felt depressed. Todays fast...

Adapting to Change is Equally Important as Adopting Change
Making changes to improve the overall success of your business should be applauded. It takes a lot of time, dedication, money, and just plain guts to...

Leading Change - Don’t Skimp on Training
Every change leader at one time or another is faced with selling training to the big guys. And what happens? The training budget, if you have one at a...

Managing Change - Size Matters - Scope The Change Work
There will come a time on every change project that you will wish you had read this article. The size and scope of the work does matter. Everyone toda...

Change Control Challenges - A Few Ways to Beat Them Up
Simply put, change control is the way that pharmaceutical, life science and technology companies (or any company for that matter) handle set-backs, "u...

Common Sense Change Control in Regulated Life Science Environments
There is no doubt that life science companies are highly regulated. Between the FDA, ISO, EMEA (Europe), CLIA and additional regulatory organizations,...

Page Bottom Paid Links (Let Me Save You From SEO Disaster)
I get asked a lot of SEO related questions and im happy to answer them, every now and again I see a question that is out of the ordinary and I think i...

Managing Change
All the talk today is about managing change in organizations. Leaders talk about it like it is really something one can manage. Everywhere I go I see ...

Management Tip - Getting to the Bottom Line
At a high level there are only two ways to grow a business: increase sales and decrease costs. Here's a simple management tip that will save you a lot...

Managing the March Toward Change
My firm works with national and international corporations to assist in identifying the need for change, establishing its direction, and managing the ...

When You May Need to Hire a Daily Money Manager
Michelle has been trying to call her mother, who lives in another state, but gets a message that the line has been disconnected. She later finds out ...